This year for Thanksgiving, I'm cooking and transporting the turkey to my brother-in-law's house. So far, that's all I've been asked to contribute, and I'm fine with it. My research showed that cooking the turkey myself is roughly half the cost of buying a fully cooked turkey, so that's what I'm doing. But of course, the best part about the Thanksgiving feast is the sides, not the turkey itself. So I'll be making side dishes and desserts that *I* want to eat, and we'll enjoy them with leftover turkey on Black Friday. But I don't want to do all the cooking at once. In fact, I can't because my hips hurt when I stand for too long. So I'll be prepping things ahead in the days leading up to Thanksgiving. What will you be cooking? (I've marked affiliate/referral links with a *, which means I may make a little bit of money if you make a purchase or sign up using that link - thank you!)
The Turkey
There were fewer turkey recipes than I expected when I looked at my Thanskgiving Pinterest board. I considered the make-ahead turkey from Ina Garten's Make It Ahead* cookbook but decided I actually want to cook the turkey on the day of. So I'm going with an LA Times recipe I've made before. This Thursday, I'll pull the 18-pound turkey I received a few days ago from ButcherBox* out of the freezer so it will be fully defrosted by Wednesday, when I'll do the dry brine overnight. Then I'll cook the turkey on Thanksgiving Day, carve it, and transport most of it in a large casserole dish.
I'll make a huge batch of gravy with the giblets and drippings while the turkey rests so I can keep some turkey and gravy back for our "leftovers feast" on Friday. (An 18-pound turkey can feed up to 18 people; there will only be 11 of us and at least three of us won't be eating turkey.)
Stuffing
I love stuffing so there are a lot of recipes for it on the Pinterest board, but my own taste leans toward meatless and white bread. It's what I grew up eating every Thanksgiving, so I don't want my stuffing to include sausage or cornbread. I have a box of Kinders Organic Stuffing* to make things easy, but I want to give this Bread Stuffing recipe a try. In fact, I'm going to make a big batch of chicken stock that will be perfect to use in it. I plan to bake the stuffing on Thursday while the turkey is cooking, since it keeps well (and I can use my countertop oven*).
Cranberry Sauce
This is the no-brainer of the group - Aunty Toki's cranberry sauce is my forever go-to recipe. I'll double the recipe, and just might triple the mandarin oranges since it's my kids' favorite part. I'll make this on Tuesday at the latest, since it keeps beautifully.
Veggies
I can't believe I'm saying this, but I'm actually no longer inclined to make the Streuseled Sweet Potato Casserole I've made for more than 20 years. My friend Annie sent me a link to Half-Baked Harvest's Crispy Parmesan Thyme Sweet Potato Stacks after raving about them, and I think I'm going to make these instead. According to the comments, they can be made a day ahead of time, so I'll prep these on Thursday while the turkey is cooking, and bake them on Friday.
The NYT recipe for Brussels Sprouts Buried in Cream is super easy and a family favorite so I'll make that on Friday also,
I'll likely pick up a package of 365 Sweet Kale Salad* at Whole Foods and toss it together on Wednesday. It keeps well, and I like the kale to get a little softer from sitting in the dressing before I eat it.
Cornbread
Just because I don't like cornbread in my stuffing doesn't mean I don't like cornbread. I picked up a box of cornbread mix from Trader Joe's a couple of weeks ago and will bake it on Friday. It's better than any cornbread I've made from scratch, and even my son who had never met a cornbread he enjoyed likes this one.
Desserts
I want a pumpkin flan from a local place called Créme Caramel. Growing up, I never liked the Japanese dessert プリン (purin or pudding), which is basically flan but was always too bitter for me as a kid. It wasn't until I had a créme caramel from Créme Caramel that I got it. Theirs is luscious and delicious and I really want one next week.
I also want to bake, though - and instead of a classic pumpkin pie, I'm looking at Love & Olive Oil's Pumpkin Custard Tart, which Lindsay describes as a "pumpkiny custard" rather than a "custardy pumpkin filling." This will be great, because it can (and should) be made a day ahead. I just have to decide whether I'll make it on Wednesday or Thursday. 😂
However, I'm the only one in my family that actually loves pumpkin desserts, so for everyone else, I'll make Smitten Kitchen's Apple Mosaic Tart. Based on the comments, I plan to make this on the day of (Friday), using store bought puff pastry and caramel sauce to make things super easy. (Between the sweet potatoes and the apples, my mandoline* is going to get a workout!)
Leftovers
I don't know how much turkey will be leftover - I'm actually contemplating cooking a turkey breast on Friday, just in case, because I'd like to have enough to make turkey pot pie hand pies. I don't have a recipe for these, although I'll work on one if there's a request. But basically, I make a very thick pot pie mixture and then sandwich it in some puff pastry. I bake at 400 degrees until browned and baked through, and wrap them individually and freeze for an easy snack or meal in the future.
Here's a list of 15 leftover turkey recipes.
I might make mashed potatoes just to have leftovers to make these Cheesy Mashed Potato Puffs.
If you happen to have leftover fresh cranberries, these sugared cranberries are delicious.
BONUS: Recipes I want to make but they don't fit my prep plans so I'll have to squeeze them in sometime during the holiday season
Corn Souffle (aka Corn Pudding) with a pound of cheese
Vegetarian Stuffed Pumpkin with mushrooms and kale that you serve as slices (click through and check out the pictures, it looks spectacular)
Brussels Sprouts, Apple and Pomegranate Salad - I just might be making this instead of the store-bought kale salad if I get ambitious
Black Sesame Rice Krispie Treats - these look so intriguing and sound delicious with the bit of freeze-dried raspberries







